Comparing Online vs Onsite Training in Allied Health

The COVID-19 pandemic has been a disruptive force that has reshaped various aspects of our lives, including the way we approach education and training in the allied health field. As social distancing measures were implemented and traditional classroom settings became a potential health risk, educational institutions and healthcare organizations were forced to adapt quickly and explore alternative modes of delivering training programs.

This unprecedented situation has accelerated the adoption of online learning platforms and virtual classrooms, allowing students and professionals in the allied health field to continue their education and skill development from the safety and convenience of their homes. However, this shift has also reignited the age-old debate: Is online training as effective as traditional onsite training when it comes to preparing individuals for careers in the healthcare industry?

In this article, we’ll discuss the nuances of online vs onsite training in allied health, exploring the advantages and disadvantages of each approach, and providing insights to help you make an informed decision that aligns with your learning preferences and career goals.

Overview of the Different Modes of Learning

Health training is designed with a systematic approach to ensure effectiveness and achieve specific health-related goals. Experts in the field put together an evidence-based curriculum that’s overseen by regulatory bodies to ensure that it’s relevant, accurate, and within current health guidelines.

They also carefully discuss the different aspects of the program to ensure its success, including instructional design, evaluation plan, implementation, and mode of delivery. Traditionally, classes are held onsite, but different modes of delivery have surfaced as time passed, thanks to emerging technology, and with its implementation expedited by the recent pandemic. Here are the most common modes of delivery currently being implemented for allied health and other courses:

Traditional/Onsite Training

This mode of learning involves attending physical classes or training sessions at a designated location, such as a college campus, hospital, or healthcare facility. Students and instructors interact in person, and hands-on practical training is often a significant component of the curriculum.

Synchronous Online Training

With this approach, students attend virtual classes or training sessions at scheduled times, typically through video conferencing platforms or virtual classrooms. Instructors deliver lectures or demonstrations in real-time, and students can participate in discussions and ask questions as they would in a traditional classroom setting.

Asynchronous Online Training

In this mode, students have access to pre-recorded lectures, course materials, and assignments, which they can complete at their own pace and convenience. There is no set schedule for live interactions, but students can still communicate with instructors and classmates through discussion forums, email, or other online channels.

Online vs Onsite Training in Allied Health: Comparing the Pros and Cons

Both online and onsite learning have their merits and drawbacks for allied health education. When comparing between the two and choosing which one to go with, there are several factors to consider, including flexibility, accessibility, cost-effectiveness, hands-on experience, and overall learning experience.

Pros of Online Training

Flexibility: Online training programs offer unparalleled flexibility, allowing students to balance their studies with work, family, or other commitments. They can access course materials and attend virtual classes from anywhere with an internet connection, eliminating the need for commuting to a physical location.
Accessibility: Online training opens up opportunities for individuals who may not have access to nearby educational institutions or healthcare facilities offering onsite programs. This is particularly beneficial for those living in remote areas or with mobility challenges.
Cost-Effectiveness: Online programs often have lower overhead costs compared to traditional onsite programs, resulting in more affordable tuition fees for students. Additionally, students can save on transportation, housing, and other expenses associated with attending an onsite program.
Self-Paced Learning: Asynchronous online training allows students to learn at their own pace, which can be particularly advantageous for those who require more time to grasp certain concepts or have other time constraints.

Cons of Online Training

Lack of Hands-On Experience: While online training can effectively deliver theoretical knowledge, it may fall short in providing hands-on practical experience, which is crucial in many allied health professions. This can be mitigated through virtual simulations or mandatory clinical rotations, but the experience may not be as immersive as onsite training.
Technical Challenges: Online learning relies heavily on technology, and technical issues such as internet connectivity problems, software glitches, or hardware malfunctions can disrupt the learning process.
Isolation and Lack of Interaction: Some students may find it challenging to stay motivated and engaged in an online learning environment, as they may feel isolated from their peers and instructors. This can be addressed through virtual study groups, discussion forums, and regular communication with instructors.
Distractions and Time Management: Online learning requires a high level of self-discipline and time management skills, as students may be tempted by distractions in their home environment or struggle to maintain a consistent study routine.

Pros of Onsite Training

Hands-On Experience: Onsite training in allied health programs typically includes a significant component of hands-on practical training, such as clinical rotations, simulations, and laboratory sessions. This direct experience is invaluable in developing the skills and confidence needed for various healthcare professions.
Face-to-Face Interaction: Onsite training allows for direct interaction with instructors and classmates, fostering a collaborative learning environment and facilitating immediate feedback and clarification of concepts.
Access to Facilities and Equipment: Students attending onsite programs have access to specialized facilities, equipment, and resources that may not be readily available in an online or home setting.
Structured Learning Environment: The structured nature of onsite programs can provide a more disciplined and focused learning environment, minimizing distractions and promoting better time management.

Cons of Onsite Training

Lack of Flexibility: Onsite training often requires students to attend classes or training sessions at specific times and locations, which can be challenging for those with work or family commitments.
Geographic Limitations: Students may be limited to attending programs within a reasonable commuting distance, restricting their options and potentially requiring relocation or lengthy commutes.
Higher Costs: Onsite programs typically have higher tuition fees and additional expenses, such as transportation, housing, and other living costs associated with attending a physical location.
Limited Accessibility: Individuals with mobility challenges or those living in remote areas may face difficulties accessing onsite training programs, limiting their educational opportunities.

Will There Still Be an Onsite Component for Online Learning in Allied Health

While online training has gained significant traction in the allied health field, it is important to note that most programs still require an onsite component, particularly for hands-on practical training and clinical experiences. This is because many allied health professions involve direct patient care or the use of specialized equipment, which cannot be fully replicated in a virtual environment.

One common example of an onsite component in online allied health programs is the practicum or internship. During this phase, students are typically required to complete a certain number of clinical hours or rotations at approved healthcare facilities or clinics. This hands-on experience is crucial for developing the necessary skills and gaining real-world exposure to the healthcare environment.

Additionally, some online programs may require students to attend occasional on-campus sessions or workshops for specific training or assessments that cannot be effectively conducted online.

It is essential for prospective students to carefully review the program requirements and understand the onsite components involved, as they may need to make arrangements for travel, temporary housing, or other logistical considerations.

So Which Should You Choose?

When it comes to choosing between online or onsite training in allied health, there is no one-size-fits-all solution. The decision ultimately depends on your individual learning style, preferences, and personal circumstances.

If you thrive in a structured learning environment, prefer face-to-face interactions, and value hands-on practical experiences, onsite training may be the better option for you. However, if you require more flexibility, have geographic or mobility limitations, or prefer self-paced learning, online training could be a more suitable choice.

It’s also important to consider the specific program requirements and your career goals. Some allied health professions may require more extensive hands-on training, making onsite programs a necessity, while others may be more conducive to online learning.

Ultimately, the key is to carefully evaluate your learning preferences, personal circumstances, and program requirements, and choose the mode of training that aligns best with your needs and aspirations.

Making the Most of Your Education: Study Tips for Online and Onsite Learning

Regardless of whether you choose online or onsite training, it’s important to adopt effective study habits and strategies to maximize your learning experience and achieve academic success. Here are some study tips to help you make the most of your online or onsite education in the health sciences:

Tips for Online Learning

Create a Dedicated Study Space: Designate a quiet, distraction-free area in your home or workspace specifically for studying and attending virtual classes. This will help you maintain focus and create a mental association with learning.
Establish a Routine: Develop a consistent study routine and schedule to help you stay organized and motivated. Create a schedule that includes a dedicated time to focus on virtual classes, assignment completion, and review of the course material.
Participate Actively: Engage with your instructors and classmates by actively participating in virtual discussions, asking questions, and contributing to online forums or chat sessions. This will help you stay engaged and enhance your understanding of the material.
Utilize Technological Resources: Become acquainted with the available online learning platforms, tools, and resources. Utilize features such as note-taking tools, virtual whiteboards, and screen-sharing capabilities to enhance your learning experience.
Be Self-Efficient and Accountable: The flexibility of online learning may make a student prone to distractions, but make sure not to get too caught up. Use calendars, to-do lists, and productivity apps to stay on top of deadlines, assignments, and virtual class schedules.

Tips for Onsite Learning

Attend Classes and Participate: Regular attendance and active participation in class discussions and activities are crucial for maximizing your learning experience in an onsite setting.
Utilize Campus Resources: Take advantage of the resources available on campus, such as libraries, study areas, tutoring services, and student support centres. These resources can enhance your learning and provide additional support when needed.
Form Study Groups: Collaborate with classmates and form study groups to review course materials, discuss concepts, and prepare for exams or assignments. Working together can reinforce your understanding and provide different perspectives.
Practice Time Management: Mastering time management is crucial for success in both online and onsite learning environments. Plan your schedule to balance class times, study sessions, extracurricular activities, and personal commitments.
Seek Guidance: Don’t hesitate to reach out to your instructors, advisors, or mentors for guidance, clarification, or additional support. Building strong relationships with faculty and staff can enhance your overall learning experience.

Start your journey towards healthcare career success with Caring Support.

Making the Most of Your Healthcare Education With Caring Support

The decision between online and onsite training in allied health ultimately comes down to your individual preferences, learning style, and personal circumstances. Both modes of learning offer unique advantages and challenges, and it’s important to carefully evaluate your options and choose the path that aligns best with your goals and aspirations. Embrace the opportunities and resources available to you, and strive to make the most of your education, whether it’s through online or onsite training.

At Caring Support, we partner with reputable institutions and organizations across Canada to help build a robust healthcare system, starting from ensuring the success of students interested in and are studying allied health training programs. So, if you’re considering pursuing a career in allied health and need guidance on choosing the right training program, our team of experts is here to help.

Contact us today for a personalized consultation to explore your options and find the perfect fit for your learning needs and career aspirations. We’ll also then help you connect with partner institutions across Canada. You may also create your free account with us today to jumpstart your career in healthcare.